Play to win, don’t play to not lose

I recently gave a talk to a room full of founder/CEOs about how to leverage your board of directors by shifting from a reporting board to a collaborative board.  It can be tricky, but for those who do it, the company and the founder can grow wings. Part of the shift involves trusting your board and bringing them into your confidence, being vulnerable with them, and asking for their help and input when things aren’t working.  This can be scary for most CEOs because the board usually has the power to remove him/her. However, if you have the right board members, and if you create the right dynamic at the board level, this usually won’t be the outcome.

One founder in the room raised his hand to challenge me. He said, and I’m paraphrasing here, “That’s a lot of ifs and usuallys. Why would I take that risk? If my board can fire me, why would I risk being fired and losing my company by admitting weakness and vulnerability?”

I love this founder for asking that question – it’s at the heart of why most CEO’s don’t go to their board with challenges.

This post has moved. Continue reading on blog.nearlynicole.com →

6 thoughts on “Play to win, don’t play to not lose”

  1. one of the best so far, Nicole. I talk about 1x per month with a founder trying to explain what you have done so simply, that creating a new relationship with your board will be better in the long run. well done! I will link to this now.

  2. Great advice, Nicole. Often the value of experience and wisdom is underestimated by (young) founders. I always ended up with a circle of trusted friends and colleagues that covered a wide age, experience and specialty range and I could be completely open with and ask for help. That is my competitive advantage.

    On one point though I like to challenge you: What does “winning” mean in business? I get your analogy of the volleyball court (mine would be basketball), it is a finite game, where score is taken and at the end there will be a winner and loser.
    However, in business I strongly believe such does not exist. Either you stay in the game, reflect, adapt, pivot or you exit. The fascination with always having to win (especially in the US) will stay a mystery to me.

    • “Winning” in business doesn’t have a simple definition, but it is simpler if you’ve raised outside capital. If you’ve raised outside capital, I would say it is returning more capital to your investors than they delivered to you, while ensuring there’s capital to distribute to the common shareholders as well. This is ‘proof’ you’ve created value in the world, rather than destroyed it.

      In addition to distributing more capital to all shareholders than you raised, I would add a handful of other qualifiers in to ‘winning’, whether you’ve raised or not.
      1. Was it a win-win-win for everyone (and I don’t mean financially, we covered that above). Did your employees walk away enriched by the experience? Did you contribute positively to your community in the process? Did you learn/grow as a person? Did everyone get BETTER because of your startup? Or did you take a ‘win-at-all-costs’ approach and many lost so you could win?
      2. Are you HAPPY? Did you end up in a position where your life is better, your emotional state is better? Are you in a more abundant spot?
      3. Did you take the bad scenarios from the experience (and yes, I know you have a lot so don’t deny it) and learn from them? Did you figure out how you’re going to do it differently and better in the future?
      4. Are you sharing your newfound wisdom and abundance with the world? Or are you hoarding?

      We could go into a long conversation about your personal finances here, but that’s a much longer conversation, and probably a whole different blog post. 🙂

  3. I love this post, Nicole. Our board was one of our biggest assets. They each brought different and complementary skills and I leaned on them all the time. We would not have had nearly as positive of an outcome without them. I made an effort to never let a month go by that I didn’t take a walk or have a call with each of them one on one. Each of my four board members has become an important mentor (and now friend) and 3 years after our exit we still go to dinner annually. They were key to ensuring our outcome was a win-win-win.

    I had the benefit of constructing my own board (with input and sign-off from our investors) and I was able to filter hard on culture fit and complimentary skillsets. I imagine many founders end up with board members they didn’t choose. How do you coach people to create the best dynamics in those situations?

    Also – I think your lists of do’s and don’ts above could each be its own post.

    • Thanks Chris – I wrote a whole series on boards, to try and tackle that exact opportunity, and it’s definitely gotten some mileage! The list of do’s and dont’s – interesting. Maybe I will, thank you for that suggestion!

Leave a Reply